www.babukisha.org (copyright 2018 -2030)

www.babukisha.org (copyright 2018 -2030)
WWW.BABUKISHAN.ORG Copyright, All Rights Reserved, Do not copy these stories or part of these stories, for your books or blogs, All Rights Reserved. 2010 -2030

Saturday, February 22, 2020

Baul, who is a Baul ? Why Baul is not just a title for anybody who sings Baul songs!!

I was contemplating what a Pandit is because I see people call themselves a Pandit, especially many westerners. I googled ‘Pandit’ I go this (Hindi; Devanagari: पण्डित; Bengali: পন্ডিত, Sanskrit: paṇḍita) is a scholar, a teacher, particularly one skilled in Sanskrit language, mastered Vedic scriptures in the four Vedas, Hindu rituals and Hindu law, religion, music or philosophy under a Guru in a Gurukul or tutored under the Vedic ancient Guru Shishya tradition of learning.” 

I said to Babu Kishan, "you are a Pandit, why don't you call yourself a Pandit." He just laughed!

Then I saw that somebody call themselves Acharya, again I google and said, "why don't you call yourself Acharya’ and again he laughed. “

In Sanskrit institutions Acharya is a Post Graduate Degree, higher learning in India of an ancient subject. 

“ Acharya is a preceptor or instructor in religious matters; leader of a sect; or a highly learned person or a title affixed to the names of advanced learning within a lineage or sect.

Then I said to Babu you have done all of this so you are an Acharya?
He said, "I am a Baul, to call one self a Baul, includes all of the above, Pandit, Acharya and much more including Sadhaka, Tantric Yogi, if one calls themselves a ‘Baul' that means you are accomplished in all area’s, of Vedic, Tantric Yogic, Sadhana, Ritual and Indian way of life including Ayurveda. 

However, today every beggar, Baul singer, call themselves Baul, Baul is extinct and one can call it a cultural genocide by modern peoples who have appropriated Baul, taken the names off the stories and put there own names forward. Many are not even from Birbhum but they are using Babu Kishan’s life stories that he lived in their books, they copy everything and make his stories generic. 

They dress his lineages dress, even the dress that Babu Kishan designed, they dance as Nabani Das Khyapa Baul but say they are from another lineage. They sing the songs of this lineage taking the names off, and taking credit where credit is appropriated. They even follow this lineage around the world, they call themselves Music Composers when they are not.

They ride constantly on the coat tails of this lineage. Even his own brothers steal from Babu Kishan aka Krishnendu Das, they steal his music, his property, forge his signature, call them selves music composers, but yet have they are not, they have not done any work. Therefore, it is not just outsider, it comes from within. 

BabuKishan.org explains what it takes to be a Music Composer.
What people think is Baul and what is Baul is something different, most people who are calling themselves Baul in Bengal are not because Baul is extinct. Baul was an ocean!!
Babu Kishan aka Krishnendu and the Late Ravi Shankar, was an old family friend, many many stories to be told.
HEY - Baul writers, it is not your story to tell about any of these people and to turn the story Generic Baul and make associations that never existed. 

I have recently been told by some Scholars this is a Cultural Appropriation and a seeing the extinct nature (cultural loss) of the Bauls any made up fake stories or association that never existed is called Cultural Genocide. 

Same with Scholars who write generalizations, taking Babu Kishan's stories. I have learned apparently there is a new way to report these story thefts and appropriations.

Really tired of it, if you do not know, don't steal another's stories and make false associations and just attribute it to Baul. I have seen Baul now has a Padma Sree or Baul is associated with Allen Ginsberg, Bob Dylan, or George Harrison because no YOUR Baul was did not nor did they ever associate or meet.



#Baulhistory #baularchive #BaulofBengal #BaulofBirbhum #India #Bengal #Kolkata #Bauldocumentary #baulkirtan #Baul #kolkata #Baultantra #ginsberg #bobdylan #Baulsadhana 

#ektara #EkachakraBirbhum #gopiyantra  #baultantra #NabonidasKhyapabaul  #Baularchive  #bauldocumentary #baulsangeet  #RabindranathTagore #BaulTagore #shantiniketanbhirbum #jainitai #jaiguru #NityanandaofEkachakra #BaulAvadhut #Bhirbhum #Tarapith #Kolkata #IncredibleIndia 
#India #VaishnavaBaul #TantricBaul  

Wednesday, February 12, 2020

The Riders on the Coat Tails of, The Tantric Vaishnava Bauls of Birbhum Bengal. The Cultural Appropriation of Baul, A New Book to be released soon!

NEW BOOK ON HISTORICAL BAUL FROM INSIDE THE ONE AND ONLY LINEAGE OF VAISHNAVA TANTRIC BAUL TO BE RELEASED THIS YEAR 2020 BETTER LATE THAN NEVER.

New book on Historical Baul from inside the 'One and Only Lineage of Vaishnava Tantric Baul' to be released this year 2020 better late than never. The Deconstruction Reduction of Baul by the Riders on the Coat Tails, the fake it til you make it Baul followers, of the Lineage Baul. Instead of being quiet, I am mentioning names, it has been a long time irritation always trying to be nice, while this looting of Baul philosophy and lineage just gets worse.


The Deconstruction Reduction of Baul by "The Riders on the Coat Tails, "The fake it til you make it" Baul singers.


I have read every thing ever written about Baul over the past 14 years. Babu Kishan has read all since the 1960's in Bengali, Sanskrit and English and he has written 3 books on Baul. Scholars writings are wrong. A mess of copy and paste with misleading information, reductionism, deconstruction which waters down and changes of the narrative of who and what Baul is?

What has been written about Baul, becomes a mere copy and paste over and over by scholars who skim over books because they need to write paper after paper to be recognized to get grants. Most have not mastered the Birbhum Bengali language/or Sanskrit, nor have they even spoken to the correct people, anybody will tell you they are a Baul for a few rupee's.
Understand Baul is extinct the bird, the soul which is the essence of Baul died when Nabani Das Khyapa Baul and Brajabala Dasi left the earth. 
Recently I came across new papers in Academia a web site where Academic publish papers. Babu Kishan's many decades friend the late Carol Solomon's husband has released her work on Lalon Fakir and relates him to Baul, asserting he was a Baul of Bangladesh. There is no such thing as Bangladeshi Bauls, they are not nor have they ever been from Bangladesh, Baul is a very small sect that originates from Birbhum West Bengal India (oral Sanskrit), based on Hindu or Sanatan Dharma Vaishnava Tantra Yoga.

Solomon linked Baul with Lalon Fakir (a great poet), but not a Baul, he never did Baul Sadhana. Carol makes this linkage to justify that their are Bauls of Bangladesh?
The Bangladeshi Bauls are a creation from the 1970's when East Pakistan had a war with India in the early 1970's, refugee's from Bangladesh landed on the streets of Calcutta. At that time in Calcutta Purna Das Baul was famous, he was heard constantly on 'All India Radio', he was a dream of every person and the refugee's started to sing his songs, for their super. In a new country as refugee's, they started to follow Baul, they had to survive, this is a good way to make money, begging. Begging is not something Bauls do, however, the new Baul singers called themself Baul and no one cared, but now that Baul is extinct and needs protection and preservation the real stories must be told if not for the history of Baul for my husband because it is his family, his family lineage, not yours.
For example if you are Jewish, you preserve your stories, your family, what happened to your family, if you can't understand that, understand that this is what Babu Kishan is doing his familes line, their songs and their stories and his stories and who he knows are not random and not your story to tell or copy and used randomly.
Who is Lalon Fakir (Shah) - he was a poet, a great poet but he was not a Baul and did no Baul Sadhana, nobody in Bengal even knew Lalon Fakir songs until Babu Kishan took the poetry and put music to it in the 1970's, he brought all these singers from Bangladesh and recorded them. Lalon Fakir never had a Baul Guru (a necessary element of Baul) he did not follow Baul way of life and he did not do Baul Sadhana.
There is no such thing as a Fakir Baul, Fakir is Fakir, Baul is Baul to completely different groups of people.


The song Kicchu Din Mone Mone has been culturally appropriated by Parvathy Baul, she lists a random poet as the writer and composer of the music for this song. The song was written by Babu Kishan's Grandfather and Guru, Nabani Das Khyapa Baul, it was recorded long ago by Hindustan Records, it is in Babu's preservation records. This is blatant theft of a song, it does matter, it matters alot. Baul and this lineage, the songs you sing and take credit for, belong to this family, It is not random and a cultural appropriation a disrespect to all the work Babu Kishan has done since the 1960's.
My husband is the only Baul ever - linked personally that had decades long personal relationships with Bob Dylan and the Band, George Harrison, The Rolling Stones, Allen Ginsberg.

However, Mary Young in her book on Baul will try to fool people making a linkage with Sanatana Das Baul by putting a huge picture of Sanatana Das Baul right across the page where you writes, "Baul is associated with Allen Ginsberg, Bob Dylan, George Harrison"? NO Baul is not, Sanatana Das Baul is NOT associated with these people, never ever. They are Babu Kishan's many decade friends, they are only associated with him. To distort and use Babu Kishan's story is a crime. George Harrison was Babu Kishan's dear friend, to use his story of a dear friend and try to mislead people that any other Baul was associated is nasty. Bob Dylan and The Band are Babu Kishan's friends. You have culturally appropriated Babu Kishan's story and made a lie and randomly at the end of your book mention Purna Das Baul names as if he is a drop.
My dear all Bauls follow Nabani Das Baul, Purna Das Baul and Babukishan, all Bauls dress as they do, they dance as they do, they sing their songs and follow them around the world, they use their stories but take their names off, this is cultural appropriation and each and every point will come out in this new book, it is has to you are watering down, stealing stories and writing about his lineage of Nitai but cutting names off, making up associations and stories.
This is a false wrong and random linkage to these association who are only friends of Babu Kishan. Purna Das Baul met Bob Dylan in 1967 however, it was Lakshman Das Baul his younger brother who Bob Dylan always asked Babu Kishan about?

It was Babu Kishan who contacted and maintained a personal relationship not Purna Das Baul and no other Bauls were associated. How can people do this, how can Mary Young write such garbage and make these associations? Cheating and riding on the coat tails of Babu Kishan's life and story.
If you are going to tell history do not do this, make false assumption and a lie, these are Babu Kishan's stories to tell, they are not random and no other Bauls or lineage is associated so why use Babu Kishan's stories and cut his name off.
Why does M Young use Nityananda of Ekchakra, when he is the ancestors of this family, everybody who writes about Baul knows that. Nitai was not a Nath only someone outside of Baul would make that assumption. Nitai was a Vaishnava Baul Avadhuta. I can not believe the inaccuracies and the cherry picking to make yourself and group look like you know.
How would you feel if someone stole your families story, cut your names off and added names that are not from your lineage, a case of pure Cultural Appropriation.
No other Baul ever used 'Lineage ever' except Babu Kishan now all these new lineages pop up?? In a way I am afraid to release Babu Kishan's book because all the vultures take the names of the story off will copy and paste and claim the story as their own.
Sanatan Das Baul never met or was associated with any the above mentioned people, why mislead people posting a picture of him beside Babu Kishan's story, it is Babu Kishan's story to tell NOT yours to make false linkages?
Mary Young writes about all the things I have written about, cherry picking and tries to link it to Parvathy Baul, and Sanatan Das Baul to this lineage without even knowing or doing research. I read her first book it did not include these, all changed on line?
The real stories will be told and they are not always enlightened because of speculations because of unqualified speculations and lack of a historical background by writers and scholars and hey what do you have to loose, it is just a job, it is not your family?
The story of Baul is the same as any indigenous peoples of the planet, colonization, refugee's who followed this lineage and admitted to riding on the coat tails. The story has to be told, as to why the Baul are now extinct and the preservation accurately needs to happen.
Baul is not Muslim and not from Bangladesh or that area of Bengal when it was Bengal India, Baul is from Birbhum, Babu Kishan can prove this, he archived Baul decades ago, he recorded the songs, long ago.
The new Baul singers like to say Baul was not recorded, they did not record only because it is their way of faking their way to fundraise. It is a way of qualifying themselves by default, because they can not explain the songs or who the poets were, so lets just tell people, these songs do not belong to anybody, they were not recorded. That is a bold faced lie, the poetry has been recorded, it is just that it does not belong to you, it is not your family history but a great way to fame and fundraising. Baul has been recorded, and preserved, when ever you see or read any Baul singer say, Baul did not record their song, they did not keep records, it is an oral tradition, Baul did not care, they are lying, complete distortion and lie. If someone asked Babu Kishan that he would say, yes I have recorded most of our songs, I have written them down. We have manuscripts stored away. He would also, say our oral tradition is a Oral Sanskrit tradition.
Let me say this clearly, Baul cares, only someone who is faking Baul would say Baul does not care and never recorded their songs?
Babu Kishan has categorized all the folk music of India for all the top music companies of India, he has a Masters degree in the folk music and music of India, he is a Oral and Classically trained Sanskritist from birth.
Babu Kishan recorded Baul poems and songs long ago, his ancestors recorded them through the oral tradition and manuscripts going way back. Stop making people stupid.
When the new book on historical Baul is released, when all is exposed, including Babu Kishan's old friend the late Carol Solomon who really did wrong in linking Lalon Fakir to Baul.
Carol Solomon was a good friend of Babu's he helped her endlessly with her Bengali language and her study of Baul, even signing and giving information for a grant application. We both saw her at her home in Seattle for dinner in 2008, it is very sad it was the last time.
She cut him out and to get the grant because so many scholars have already written about Baul, turned the project towards linking Baul to Bangladesh through Lalon Fakir, what do these people care, it is just a job, it is not their family or their ancient lineage? This is just a drop, the truth must be told.
You need to know it was Rabindranath Tagore who first talked about Lalon Fakir, but the only Baul associated with Tagore was Nabani Das Khyapa Baul, I have written about this long time association in other writings, many have tried to make this association too and it is not true. Same with Allen Ginsberg he wrote a song called Lalon and everybody makes a linkage but if you read the poetry it has nothing to do with Lalon. Allen Ginsberg first met Nabani Das Khyapa Baul in 1962 and it was only Babu Kishan who had a relationship, many decades long with Allen Ginsberg but you will sell people generically link Ginsberg to them? He was not linked with any other Baul (period), Purna Das Baul met him but was not a friend, Ginsberg was only interested in talking about Nabani and other poets with Babu Kishan because Babu and Ginsberg are both poets. The only Baul song Allen Ginsberg wrote ever, was written as gift to Babu Kishan in honour of Nabani Das Khyapa Baul. How people twist and culturally appropriate Babu Kishan's story.
So why would anybody ever link Allen Ginsberg's name with Baul without using Babu Kishan's name? How can you write about Rabindranath Tagore and Baul without using Nabani Das khyapa Baul's name, he is the Baul Guru who initiated Tagore into Baul giving him the name Ravi Baul. Please read Babu Kishan's blog on Babukishan.org for details.
It was NOT Lee Lozowick who brought Baul to the west, trash writing on academia, it was first Purna Das Baul and the group called the 'Bauls of Bengal' it was Allen Ginsberg and the Grossman's. Then Babu kishan did all the work there after and made all the associations, meeting making friends, it was a lot of work, writing letters, making contact, arranging programs, lecturing at Universities around the world.
Babu Kishan created a template for all Bauls to follow and they do, they follow him around the world making up false stories, teaching wrong teaching, fundraising only for their selfish reason acting like they are the saviour of Baul.
Do not take credit away from the indigenous peoples.
All Bauls follow this lineage, they follow how they dress, they sing their songs, they even follow them around the world and go and meet their friends.
I wish they would stop all their lying copy and pasting and cheating and making up new lineages and stories that belong to Babu Kishan's biography, randomly mentioning his stories but taking his name off his story, like as if it were you, you were the one who had met these people. They have always followed Babu Kishan including trying for his Bollywood connections? Saying they are composers, do you know what a composer is and how hard it is to be a composer, you have to have a body of successful work, tested, and certified by well known composers, again (see BabuKishan.org to find out what it took to be a Music Composer)?? I have seen a Baul write, Baul now has a Padma Sri, what the heck, Baul does not, use the name of the Baul, Purna Das Baul has a Padma Shree, no other random generic Baul, it is an insult not to use names.
I have seen someone advertise teaching Baul Tantra using the chapters and subjects listed right out Purna Das Baul's 500 page book on Baul and then stating she has never heard of another Baul book except for Mary Young's book and nobody else has written a book, huge lie, huge cultural appropriation.
Cultural Appropriation of an Indigenous peoples, riding on the coat tails of this lineage without giving credit.
#Babukishan #Baularchive #baulhistory #bauldocumentary, #baulmusic #baulofbengal #kolkata #bengal #baulmusic #baul #culturalappropriation #baultantra